Sweet Traditions

The sweetest memories are homemade.

All menu items are scratch made from family recipes. I have always enjoyed baking and would always be asked to "bring the dessert". Upon the "not so subtle" urging of a great friend (DW), I made a flyer to see if there would be any interest in my recipes. To my surprise, everyone thought it was such a refreshing idea to offer "ordinary" and "traditional" cakes! So, in honor of all the amazing women who chose to "show me" rather than "shoo me"... Sweet Traditions was born!

I hope my cakes take you back to your grandma's house, too!

SPECIAL REQUESTS ACCEPTED.

Disclosure: Home baked items. Scratch made. Operating under Ohio's Cottage Law.

Columbus, Ohio, USA
Kelly Cotton, Owner & Baker

sweettraditions411@gmail.com
10am - 6pm Sunday - Saturday

The sweetest memories are homemade. All items are made from scratch. Kitchen is not nut free. Menu is subject to change based upon availability of ingredients.

Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Pineapple cake with crushed pineapple

Aunt Nina's 7-Up Pound Cake

Hummingbird Cake

Moist cake flavored with fresh bananas, pineapple, cinnamon, cream cheese frosting and topped with pecans.

Auntie's Banana Pudding

Pucker Up Lemon

Fresh lemon cake with lemon buttercream frosting

Margarita

Various seasonal flavors available. *This is an adult treat. (Additional liquor boost...pipettes - $1ea OR mini bottle - $3ea)

Smooth Vanilla

Light and moist vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream frosting.

It's Chocolate

Delicious chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream frosting

Bundt Cakes

12" Full, 8" Mini, 3" Itty Bitty Red velvet, lemon, vanilla, strawberry, chocolate All with buttercream frosting. Caramel sauce - Add $3 Ganache - Add $3

Pound Cakes

Full size 12", Singles 6" Flavors: Butter, Vanilla, Lemon, Strawberry, Rum, Orange

You're Special Cake

Buttercream and fruit filling in between layers of moist vanilla cake. Dressed in fluffy buttercream. Sizes: 10" 2 layer, 6" 3 layer Flavors: Raspberry, Strawberry, Blackberry, Blueberry, Peach

Glazed Perfection

Choose your cake flavor. Topped with beautiful, shiny glaze.

Buckeye Cake

Moist chocolate cake layered with fluffy peanut butter buttercream and covered in rich, chocolate ganache. Avail in 10" and 6" You may purchase additional Buckeyes by the dozen.

Chocolate Shots

Handmade chocolate shot glasses filled with homemade mousse. Available in Adult version.

Kelly, I just wanted to let you know that these cupcakes are the (BOOOOOOOM). For anyone that is wondering how they taste, they taste AWESOME! I will be purchasing another box very soon! Thank you again...happy baking!
Robin Kelly-Williams

Kelly's strawberry margarita cupcakes are so sweet and yummy! They are so fresh. You can literally tell the cupcakes were made with love! I will definitely purchase more. Please shop with her you won't regret it!
Chermel Cotton

Thank you Kelly for contributing to the pre-birthday lineup for Mo...The sampling shall begin, pineapple upside down cake and lemon cake with lemon buttercream frosting... YUMMY!
Marcus J. Salter

I would recommend it all! When you bite into the cakes or cupcakes, it takes you back to your childhood. The hummingbird cake is sooooo delicious and the icing is to die for!!!
Shanece Williams

I had my first cupcake from Sweet Traditions yesterday. The strawberry margarita cupcake was amazing! Best cupcake I have EVER had. Do yourself a favor and place an order!
Mary Davis-Townsend

OMG! your cupcakes are the TRUTH! Sis, you are gifted!
Mary Davis-Townsend

Those lemon cupcakes are FIRE!
Ciara Jones

Kelly, everything was GREAT! Thank you!
Mo Turner

Cupcakes by Kelly... Soooooo good! Even my picky kid gave the thumbs up! The tequila for me and the lemon for them. Thanks again!
Paris Lightner

Chocolate cake with the caramel is the BOMB!
Ciara Jones

OMG! Kelly these are the best cupcakes I have tasted in my almost 63 years of life. Thank you!
Georgann Carter

Guys, legit, some of the best cupcakes I have ever had. I will be getting more and not sharing so...you better get you some!
Christy Gre

Soooooo yummy! You deserve it Kelly!
Cathy Golden

Just had the cakes...delicious...my dad said he is a ckae connoisseur and he would rate it a 5!! So yummy! My dad is still talking about them!!! And the boys chowed down on them!!!
Becky Pepper

Thank you for the cup cakes. They are delicious!!! I ate half a one when she dropped them off. I was still full from dinner. But I woke up early this morning and ate the other half. 😋. I have a half of one left and hear it calling me now. LOL. They are GOOD! Thanks again!
Shirley Moyer

My carrot cake is delicious! Perfect level of sweetness and moisteness. Thank you! ❤
Ms. Carter

OMG! My mom was so happy! She smiled through the entire first bite and all through the rest of her first piece. Thank you so so much! It is delicious. (Aunt Nina's 7Up cake)
Linda Freeman Walker

Thank you my friend you are the bomb and your product is the bomb! 2021 will be amazing to you and your business my friend remember I told you that!
Robin Carroll

OMG! My mom was so happy! She smiled through the entire first bite and all through the rest of her first piece. Thank you so so much! It is delicious. Have a very happy holiday and Thanksgiving.
Linda Freeman Walker

Thank you my friend you are the bomb and your product is the bomb! 2021 will be amazing to you and your business my friend, remember I told you that!
Robin Carroll

Good Morning Kelly, Thank you so much for the tasty cupcakes. The kiddos enjoyed them. I just had another cupcake this morning lol (cheating I know) no judgement
Vanity

Hummingbird Cake
Aunt Nina's 7-up Pound Cake
Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Honey, It's Chocolate! Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Hummingbird Jumbo Cupcake
Chocolate Mini Bundt with Caramel Drizzle
Pucker Up Lemon - Lemon Cake with Lemon Buttercream Jumbo Cupcakes
Honey, It's Chocolate! cupcake minis- chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream
Pucker Up Lemon - lemon cake with lemon buttercream
Hot Fudge Sundae Jumbo Cupcake
Margarita Cupcakes - vanilla cake with lime and topped with lime/tequila buttercream (made with Jose Cuervo Gold)
Peach Margarita Cupcakes - vanilla cake with white peaches topped with peach and tequila buttercream (made with Jose Cuervo Gold)
Peach Margarita Cupcake - vanilla cake with white peaches topped with peach and tequila buttercream (made with Jose Cuervo Gold)
Blackberry Cupcakes with Whipped Cream frosting
Auntie's Banana Pudding - Using Pecan Butter Cookies
Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake minis
Carrot Cake with cream cheese frosting
Red Velvet Mini Bundt Cake topped with Cream Cheese Frosting
Strawberry Margarita Cupcakes
Strawberry Margarita Cupcakes (vanilla cake with strawberries topped with strawberry and tequila buttercream (made with Jose Cuervo Gold))
Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cupcakes
Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Auntie's Banana Pudding
Red Velvet Bundt mini
Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Red velvet cupcakes
Chocolate Bundt cake with chocolate ganach
Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon glaze
Strawberry Itty Bitty Bundt with fresh strawberries
Birthday Specialty Cake
Pumpkin pound cake with maple walnut glaze
Galaxy Cake
Butter Pound Cake with glaze

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

4" Round - 2 layer

$15

Serves 1-2

6" Round - 2 layer

8" Round- 2 layer

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

10" Round - 2 layer

$65

Serves 16-20

12" Round

$90

Serves 24-40

Bundt

$40

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

1/4 Sheet (9x13)

$65

1/2 Sheet (13x18)

$100

2-Layer Sheet

$150

2 Layer 1/4 Sheet - Serves 50 = $80+
2 Layer 1/2 Sheet - Serves 80-100 = $150+

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

Mini Cupcakes

$20

by dozen
Specialty (Adult) Add $10

Regular Cupcakes

$40

by dozen
Specialty (Adult) Add $10

Jumbo Cupcakes

$50

by dozen
Specialty (Adult) Add $10

Sweet Traditions

About

Contact

Menu

The sweetest memories are homemade. All items are made from scratch. Kitchen is not nut free. ***Menu is subject to change based upon availability of ingredients.***

Menu

Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Aunt Nina's 7-Up Pound Cake

Hummingbird Cake

Auntie's Banana Pudding

Pucker Up Lemon

Margarita

Smooth Vanilla

It's Chocolate

Bundt Cakes

Pound Cakes

You're Special Cake

Glazed Perfection

Buckeye Cake

Chocolate Shots

Testimonials

Gallery

Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Carrot Cake with cream cheese frosting

Strawberry Margarita Cupcakes

Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cupcakes

Gram's Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Auntie's Banana Pudding

Red velvet cupcakes

Chocolate Bundt cake with chocolate ganach

Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon glaze

Strawberry Itty Bitty Bundt with fresh strawberries

Birthday Specialty Cake

Pumpkin pound cake with maple walnut glaze

Galaxy Cake

Butter Pound Cake with glaze

Pricing Table - Rounds

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

4" Round - 2 layer

6" Round - 2 layer

8" Round- 2 layer

Pricing Table - Large Rounds

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

10" Round - 2 layer

12" Round

Bundt

Pricing Table - Sheet cakes

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

1/4 Sheet (9x13)

1/2 Sheet (13x18)

2-Layer Sheet

Pricing Table - cupcakes

Prices listed are starting prices. May incur additional charge for special flavor/custom decoration. Prices are subject to change.

Mini Cupcakes

Regular Cupcakes

Jumbo Cupcakes

The sweetest memories are homemade. All items are made from scratch. Kitchen is not nut free. Menu is subject to change based upon availability of ingredients.